If you love that clean, crisp peppermint center surrounded by dark chocolate, this copycat recipe will save you a trip to the store. It’s straightforward, forgiving, and makes a satisfying batch of homemade peppermint patties that taste like the classic York originals. No special candy thermometer or tempering technique required for a home cook.

The method is about two parts assembly and one part patience: mix, chill, shape, then dip. The steps are short and repeatable, so you can focus on texture and flavor rather than complicated technique. It’s a great small-batch treat to make for gifts, dessert plates, or a chocolatey afternoon pick-me-up.

Read through the ingredients and the step-by-step method before you start. Set aside an afternoon snack break and a cool spot in the kitchen for chilling and drying — these patties need a little time to firm up, but the work itself moves quickly.

What You’ll Gather

4 cups powdered sugar — the base that gives the filling its structure and sweetness; sifted to avoid lumps.
⅓ cup corn syrup — adds chew and helps the filling hold together smoothly.
⅓ cup butter — provides richness and helps the filling set with a pleasant mouthfeel; room temperature is easiest to mix.
4 or 5 drops peppermint extract — concentrated mint flavor; start with 4 drops and adjust if you prefer a stronger mint punch.
8 ounces dark chocolate — the coating; choose a bar or chips you like to eat because the flavor is front-and-center.
1 tablespoon vegetable shortening — thins the chocolate slightly for easier dipping and gives a smoother finish as it sets.

The Method for Copycat York Peppermint Patties

Start by sifting the powdered sugar into a medium bowl to remove any lumps and ensure a silky filling.
Add the corn syrup, butter, and peppermint extract to the sifted powdered sugar. Use a hand mixer or stand mixer on low speed and blend until the mixture becomes smooth and holds together into a pliable dough. Scrape the bowl as needed so everything incorporates evenly.
Portion the mint mixture into bite-sized balls. A teaspoon or small cookie scoop works well for consistent sizes. Place the balls on a plate or tray lined with parchment.
Refrigerate the balls for about 20 minutes. Chilling firms them up so they are easier to shape and dip without losing form.
When you’re ready to form the patties, press each chilled ball flat with the bottom of a glass (light, even pressure). Aim for about 1/4-inch to 3/8-inch thickness depending on how thick you want the centers.
Prepare a double boiler: simmer a few inches of water in a saucepan and rest a heatproof bowl over it without touching the water. Add the dark chocolate and vegetable shortening to the bowl and stir until fully melted and smooth. Keep the chocolate warm but not too hot; it should be fluid enough to coat without being thin.
Using a fork or dipping tool, drop each peppermint patty into the melted chocolate, turn to coat completely, then lift and let excess chocolate drip off. Place the dipped patties on a silicone mat or waxed paper to set. Work quickly in small batches so the centers don’t soften from the warm chocolate.
Let the chocolate set at room temperature until firm. If your kitchen is warm, chill the tray briefly to speed setting, but avoid condensation by placing the tray in the fridge uncovered only for a short time.
Store finished patties in an airtight container at cool room temperature or in the refrigerator if your home is very warm. They keep well for several weeks when stored properly.

Why This Recipe Belongs in Your Rotation

This recipe reproducibly delivers the crisp peppermint center and a dark chocolate exterior that fans of the candy know and love. It uses pantry-friendly ingredients and minimal equipment, so you can make it on a whim. The technique is forgiving: a short chill and a gentle press create uniform patties without precision molds or special tools.

It’s also an easy gift: homemade peppermint patties feel fancy but they’re inexpensive to produce. If you enjoy making confections, this is a practical, high-reward project that introduces you to basic candy assembly and chocolate dipping without complex tempering.

Quick Replacement Ideas

Butter — can be swapped with the same amount of margarine if you need a dairy-free option, but flavor and mouthfeel will differ slightly.
Vegetable shortening — coconut oil can be used in the same amount if you prefer; it may add a subtle coconut note and can affect the set.
Dark chocolate — use semisweet or milk chocolate for a sweeter coating; expect a softer contrast with the mint center.
Peppermint extract — if you want a milder mint, reduce to 2–3 drops; for a more pronounced cooling effect, add up to 1 additional drop.

Equipment at a Glance

Mixing bowl and hand mixer or stand mixer — for combining the filling smoothly.
Sifter — for the powdered sugar.
Small cookie scoop or teaspoon — for portioning the filling evenly.
Glass or flat-bottomed object — to press balls into patties.
Double boiler or heatproof bowl set over a saucepan — for melting chocolate gently.
Forks or dipping tools and a silicone mat or waxed paper — for dipping and setting the patties.

Things That Go Wrong

Filling too sticky: If the filling feels overly tacky and won’t hold shape, chill it a bit longer. If it’s still too soft, a short rest in the refrigerator firms up the mixture.

Chocolate seizes or thickens: Make sure no water gets into the melted chocolate. If chocolate seizes, add a small bit of shortening and warm gently while stirring to smooth it out. Work in small batches when dipping to avoid reheating the chocolate repeatedly.

Patties lose shape while dipping: Chill the patties until firm before pressing and dipping. Also keep the melted chocolate at a moderate temperature so the centers don’t soften on contact.

Variations by Season

Winter

Add a tiny pinch of flaky sea salt on top of each patty just after dipping for a festive contrast to the mint and chocolate.

Spring

Use pastel-colored candy sprinkles pressed lightly into the coating before it sets for a playful look (add sparingly to preserve the classic taste).

Holiday

Dip half of each patty and drizzle white chocolate over the dark for a two-tone effect that reads festive on gift trays.

Cook’s Commentary

This is one of those recipes where tactile feedback matters: you’ll know the filling is right when it feels smooth and slightly pliant, not crumbly or overly wet. I prefer dark chocolate because it balances the sweet mint center, but use what you enjoy eating. The key is chilling at the right moments — that’s what keeps the patties neat when you dip them.

Also, don’t overthink the dipping stage. A quick dunk and gentle tap to remove excess chocolate gives a thin, even coating. If you want a glossy finish, place patties in a warmer room to allow the chocolate to set slowly rather than shocking them in the fridge, which can cause bloom or dullness.

Leftovers & Meal Prep

Store patties in an airtight container layered between sheets of parchment to prevent sticking. They’ll keep at cool room temperature for up to two weeks, or longer refrigerated. If you plan to gift them, keep them in a box with a tight seal and include parchment between layers. Freezing is possible for longer storage; freeze in a single layer until solid, then transfer to a sealed container with layers of parchment. Thaw gently in the fridge before serving.

Ask the Chef

Q: Can I make the filling ahead? — A: Yes. Make the filling, shape into balls, and refrigerate up to 48 hours before pressing and dipping. Bring them back to cold temperature just before dipping.
Q: Do I need to temper the chocolate? — A: No. The small amount of shortening helps the chocolate set smoothly without formal tempering for home use.
Q: My chocolate looks dull after setting. Why? — A: Rapid cooling can cause bloom or dullness. Let set at a moderate room temp for the best sheen, or use a bit more shortening if you prefer a glossier finish.

Let’s Eat

Arrange your patties on a plate or stack them in a box for gifts. Take a bite: you want a clean snap of chocolate followed by a cold, minty center that’s not too sweet. Serve with coffee, tea, or just enjoy one as a little reward. These are easy to scale up for parties and always disappear fast.

Print Recipe Save it for later